Jose Luis Magana / AP
Former Defense Secretary Leon Panetta speaks a news conference at the Pentagon on Nov. 29, 2012.
A Tampa, Fla., socialite subjected to intense media attention in connection with the scandal that cost former CIA Director David Petraeus his job on Friday accused current and former high-level U.S. government officials—former Defense Secretary Leon Panetta and the deputy director of the FBI – of leaking personal details and violating her privacy rights as part of a “malicious smear campaign.”
The new allegations, first reported by NBC News, are contained in an amended lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C., by Jill Kelley and her physician husband ,Scott. Among other things, the lawsuit charges that the Kellys’ names, emails and personal information were improperly leaked to the media by government officials in the days after Petraeus resigned on Nov. 9, 2012.
“Numerous employees of the FBI and the DOD (Department of Defense) unlawfully and recklessly disseminated inaccurate, derogatory, and irrelevant information obtained” from federal records “to media members and other third parties who were not authorized to received such information,” the complaint says. As a result, it alleges, “Mrs. Kelley’s reputation is indelibly tainted.”
The Kelleys inadvertently triggered the investigation that led to Petraeus’ departure in the spring of 2012 when they reported to the FBI that they had received harassing and threatening emails from an anonymous cyber-stalker. The harassing emails were later traced to Petraeus’ biographer, Paula Broadwell, with whom he acknowledged having a sexual affair.
In the aftermath of Petraeus’ resignation, Jill Kelley came under media scrutiny because of her close social ties to top U.S. military and intelligence officials, many of whom she had met at parties thrown at her home near MacDill Air Force Base, the headquarters of the U.S. Central Command. Her revised lawsuit—with new allegations and named defendants—updates a complaint that she and her husband first filed in federal court in June.
The Justice Department, which is representing all the defendants in the case, recently moved to dismiss the earlier complaint on the grounds that the Kelleys lacked standing to sue and sufficient evidence of wrongful acts – arguing that any information disclosed was not covered by the federal Privacy Act. A spokeswoman for the Justice Department declined comment Friday on the revised complaint.
Chris O'meara / AP
Jill Kelley leaves her home in Tampa, Fla., on Nov 13, 2012.
The amended complaint is in part designed to ramp up pressure on the Justice Department to engage in settlement talks by making new claims and naming high-profile defendants and witnesses who would likely be subpoenaed if the case proceeds, according to sources familiar with Kelley’s legal strategy.
Among other things, the lawsuit alleges that Deputy FBI Director Sean Joyce, who is due to retire next month, then-FBI director Robert Mueller, Attorney General Eric Holder and other top Obama administration officials made decisions about the Petraeus investigation “based on the timing of the (2012) presidential election.” As NBC News reported earlier this month, that allegation is based largely on the account of a Florida-based FBI agent, a friend of Jill Kelly’s who she first told about the harassing emails.
Alex Wong / Pool / EPA
Deputy FBI Director Sean Joyce shakes hands with President Barack Obama during a swearing-in ceremony for FBI Director James Comey on Oct. 28.
The lawsuit also cites statements that Jeh Johnson, then the general counsel of the Defense Department and now President Obama’s nominee to be homeland security secretary, made in an interview with the Tampa Tribune in July. In the interview, Johnson said that his review of several years of Jill Kelly’s emails provided to him by the FBI showed a “potentially inappropriate relationship” with Army Gen. John Allen, the former U.S. commander in Afghanistan.
After Johnson completed his review in November 2012, Panetta publicly announced he was asking the Defense Department inspector general to investigate Allen’s emails with Kelley. The lawsuit charges that Panetta’s disclosure about the emails wrongly revealed personal information about Jill Kelley. (The inspector general’s investigation found no wrongdoing by Allen. Both Allen, who has since retired, and Kelley have denied any improper relationship.)
Panetta declined to comment on the lawsuit.
The lawsuit also includes as an exhibit a fax that was sent to Kelley on Nov. 11, 2012, the day Petraeus’ resignation was announced, by Douglas Frantz, then the national security editor of the Washington Post, which said, “We have now seen some of the harassing emails she (Broadwell) sent to you.” The complaint says the fax from Frantz—who is now assistant secretary of state for public affairs – shows that officials in the government had leaked Kelley’s name and were “disseminating her emails to the press.”
Johnson did not respond to a request for comment. Frantz, who serves as Secretary of State John Kerry’s chief of public affairs, also declined comment. “The fax speaks for itself,” he said in an email.
Kelley’s name first became public last November when it was revealed that her complaints to the FBI in June of 2012 about the anonymous harassing emails she and her husband received had triggered the investigation that led to Petraeus’ resignation. According to the revised complaint, the emails began in the spring of 2012 and made references to private social meetings Kelley was having with senior military and public officials. Kelley reported the emails to a friend of hers, Fred Humphries, an agent in the bureau’s Tampa office, and the FBI launched a “cyber-stalking” investigation.
Although the emails were eventually traced to Broadwell, Kelley’s complaint alleges both she and Humphries wrongly came under suspicion. According to the complaint, Humphries has told Kelley that, even after Broadwell was identified as the author of the emails, the FBI “had a chart posted up on the wall, visible to anyone in its Tampa Field Office, showing Mrs. Kelley at the hub with spokes drawn out to several senior government and military officials… The chart and other conduct of the agents demonstrated a discriminatory and sexist fascination with Mrs. Kelley.”
The FBI also declined to comment.
More from NBC News Investigations:
- Teen suspect in murder of teacher Colleen Ritzer left 'hate' note, documents say
- Jimmy Breslin, the gravedigger and 'the bleary day' they buried JFK
- $5 million bail ordered for suspect in Oregon prosecutor bombing case
Read and vote on readers' story tips and suggested topics for investigation or submit your own.